Calling for the Expulsion of Theodore Beale from SFWA

Recently, N. K. Jemisin delivered her Guest of Honour speech at Continuum in Australia. It is an excellent and important speech. In it, she mentions that roughly 10% of the ballots cast in the recent SFWA  Presidential election went to a man who is unabashedly racist, misogynistic, and just generally hateful in an astoundingly relentless sort of way. She does this in order to talk about how important it is to not be an enabler of that kind of hatred through one’s silence.

She doesn’t name him in her speech, and more power to her. He has, however, responded to her on his blog, so I will tell you here that his name is Theodore Beale, also known as Vox Day, whom I only encourage you to google if your day is suffering from a surfeit of happiness and sunshine. Here, however, are some relevant screenshots, posted with warnings for truly vicious racism and misogyny:

Beale screenshot 1 Beale screenshot 2

Beale’s response to Jemisin’s speech was astonishing. It was astonishing not so much because it was racist and disgusting in a way to do D. W. Griffith proud, which it unequivocally is, but rather because it turned up in my Twitter feed via SFWA Authors, a Twitter account designed to automatically retweet posts from members with the appropriate hashtag. This is their stated policy:

Not every blog post is appropriate for @sfwaauthors. If a post is not about writing, or about fiction or publishing, do not mark it for inclusion in the @sfwaauthors twitter feed. Repeated violations of this policy will be grounds for removal from the feed. SFWA reserves the right to determine what posts are appropriate.

Marking blog posts for inclusion that include threats or personal attacks or obvious trolling will also be grounds for removal.

(Emphasis mine.)

I believe the act of singling out this particular post for dissemination by SFWA Authors to be an act of deliberate, malicious trolling with intent to cause embarrassment to SFWA’s officers and the organization as a whole. I further believe this act should have consequences that SFWA is in a position to deliver.

I just sent the following e-mail to Sean Williams, Overseas Regional Director of SFWA, copying the rest of the board. I urge any other SFWA members who feel the same way to contact your own regional directors and feel free to borrow any language of mine you feel is useful.

The board’s addresses are as follow, with the last five being Western Region, South Central Region, Eastern Region, and Overseas Region respectively.,,,,,,,,


Dear Sean Williams,

I am writing to you as my regional representative in SFWA, wishing to express my desire to see Theodore Beale (aka Vox Day) expelled from SFWA immediately.So far as I have read on SFWA’s website, a by-law of the organization reads as follows:

Section 10. Expulsion of Member. The officers of the Corporation may, by unanimous vote, expel any member for good and sufficient cause. In the event of such expulsion, the said member’s dues, if paid, shall be refunded on a pro rata basis. If a member so expelled is a life member, the refund shall be the life membership fee paid by the member minus $50 per year elapsed since the life membership was purchased. A member so expelled shall be reinstated upon petition of two-thirds of the active membership. The Corporation shall have no responsibility to circulate the petition.

While it is my personal feeling that the hateful, harmful, dehumanizing views expressed by Beale on his blog (about women, about religious and ethnic groups to which he does not belong, about queer people) would be “good and sufficient cause” enough to not share an organisation with him, I understand that enforcing expulsion on those grounds is problematic in the absence of an expansive organization-wide Code of Conduct.

However, Mr Beale has repeatedly and aggressively used SFWA platforms to broadcast and disseminate these views with obvious malicious intent. Most recently he has used the SFWA Authors Twitter feed — in flagrant contravention of its terms of use — to broadcast an appallingly racist screed against author N. K. Jemisin, calling her an “ignorant half-savage” and saying that “self-defense laws have been put in place to let whites defend their lives and their property from people, like her, who are half-savages engaged in attacking them.”

This last reads to me very much like a threat, especially coming from a white man to a black woman in a country where public lynchings are a matter of living memory.

I urge you to please represent my views to the rest of the officers and vote to expel a man who has behaved so execrably from our organization.


Amal El-Mohtar

This entry was posted in Uncategorized. Bookmark the permalink.

67 Responses to Calling for the Expulsion of Theodore Beale from SFWA

  1. The SFWA seems to have trouble setting boundaries! They should expel Beale from the organization so fast they use time travel to do it.


  2. Pingback: Carrie Cuinn | Wishing Never Changed A Damn Thing

  3. Pingback: A glimpse at the racism lurking around science fiction | Tobias Buckell Online

  4. Pingback: Jim C. Hines » Racist Takes Dump in SFWA Twitter Stream: News at 11

  5. Pingback: Time for Sunlight and Dettol | Where Worlds Collide

  6. Pingback: Oh. Dear. God. | Spider's Web

  7. Pingback: Personal, Professional, Official? Standards of Professionalism in SFWA | The King of Elfland's Second Cousin

  8. Pingback: » Silence equals consent: a brief letter I sent to SFWA (or The First Officialish Thing I Did as a Member)

  9. Pingback: SFWA woes | Bennett North

  10. Pingback: Reconciliation: A Response To Theodore Beale | shattersnipe: malcontent & rainbows

  11. Pingback: Their Fear is Justified (or Why Speaking Out In Your Community Is Important) | Make Me a Sammich

  12. Pingback: More fallout from the SFWA controversy |

  13. Pingback: Reconciliation within the SFF genre, one writer at a time (or finally getting around to the SWFA kerfuffle) | The Cafe in the Woods

  14. Pingback: Fall-out from N.K. Jemisin's Continuum 9 GoH speech

  15. Pingback: somewhat past time | Crime and the Blog of Evil

  16. Pingback: Sexism in writing & publishing: a romance perspective | Jessa Slade

  17. Pingback: Are You Shocked? | K. Tempest Bradford

  18. Pingback: This Week in Racist Bullshit — Radish Reviews

  19. Pingback: Let’s Do Equations Involving Assholes | Ferrett Steinmetz

  20. Pingback: More SFWA Stuff

  21. Pingback: SFWA: It gets worse… | Cora Buhlert

  22. Pingback: Theodore Beale and how organizations get poisoned from within. | Fiction

  23. Pingback: I Really Don’t Give a Shit About Vox Day | mostprobablystrange

  24. Pingback: Open Letter to SFWA | Jenny's Library

  25. Pingback: SFWA, hate speech, and standing up for what is right | Diodati L.O.D.G.E.

  26. Pingback: I, For One, Have Had Enough | R.S.A.Garcia

  27. Pingback: How to Listen. | The Way Forward Machine

  28. Pingback: On SFWA: Making Bigots Unwelcome | Alex Dally MacFarlane

  29. Pingback: You know it’s a form rejection letter— | Fraser Sherman's Blog

  30. Pingback: Through Dangers Untold and Hardships Unnumbered - The Murverse Annex

  31. Pingback: Jo Fletcher Books, Rod Rees, Sexism, and Systemic Failure. Part II. | Between the Devil and the Deep Blue Sea

  32. Pingback: Jo Fletcher Books, Rod Rees, Sexism and Systemic Failure. Part IV. | Between the Devil and the Deep Blue Sea

  33. Pingback: A Timeline of the 2013 SFWA Controversies

  34. Pingback: Sexism, Racism and the SFWA | Jack Lusted

  35. Pingback: Фантастичният англоезичен интернет с Александър Косулиев (Юли 2013) | Сборище на трубадури

  36. Pingback: When my son grows up, I hope he is like his dad. If not, I hope he is like this guy. | Kelly Barnhill

  37. Pingback: SFWA Expels Member - Science Fiction Fantasy Chronicles: forums

  38. Pingback: Links to Chew On: The Great Library | The Undiscovered Author

  39. Pingback: By the Numbers: An Analysis of the Reviews Deleted in the Goodreads Policy Change | Soapboxing

  40. Pingback: Black Gate » Blog Archive » Tales From Windy City Pulp and Paper

  41. Pingback: Hugo-nominated Vox Day: Even worse than you think | we hunted the mammoth

  42. Pingback: A Not-So-Brief Followup on the Hugo Controversy-Fest | Mountain Was Here

  43. Pingback: Dear John C Wright: Please stop lying. ← Rachael Acks: Sound and Nerdery

  44. Pingback: Silence Is Not Synonymous With Uproar: A Response To John C. Wright | shattersnipe: malcontent & rainbows

  45. Pingback: An intriguing point | The "Professional" Blog of J. M. Brink

  46. Pingback: Going through Hugo recommendations | Spacefaring, Extradimensional Happy Kittens

  47. Pingback: Sad Puppies and the Hugo Awards | Ed Fortune

  48. Pingback: Hugo Award nominations spark row over diversity in sci-fi | dubaidailypress

  49. Pingback: The Hit Piece That Released the Kraken | Jason Cordova's Website

  50. Pingback: Dragons and Puppies and Bards, Oh My! 4/9 | File 770

  51. Pingback: Hijacking the Hugo Awards Won’t Stifle Diversity in Science Fiction – The Atlantic | Great books outlet

  52. Pingback: Hijacking the Hugo Awards Won’t Stifle Diversity in Science Fiction – The Atlantic | Pet Supply Sale

  53. Pingback: The Hugo Affair | POCGamer

  54. Pingback: Right wing trolls take over the Hugo Awards |

  55. Pingback: Buzz Worthy News: April 13, 2015 | Cuddlebuggery Book Blog

  56. Pingback: How Gamergate Hijacked the Hugo Awards | VG boundaries 4

  57. Pingback: Crisis on one Earth

  58. Pingback: Sad Puppies' Hijacking of the Hugo Awards Won't Stifle Diversity in Science Fiction — The Atlantic

  59. Pingback: Correction: Hugo Awards voting campaign sparks controversy |

  60. Pingback: Science Fiction’s White Boys’ Club Strikes Back – The New Republic | Great books outlet

  61. Pingback: | The Today Online

  62. Pingback: Vol. 2 / No. 25.2 — Feminist Friday: “Depressed Baby Dogs” Edition | ThisWeekInTomorrow

  63. Pingback: Sad/Rabid Puppies Flatline in 2015 Hugo Awards » Krypton Radio

  64. Pingback: Black Gate » Blog Archive » Camestros Felapton on The True History of the Great Puppy Kerfuffle of 2015

  65. Pingback: Just A Reminder. | The Arts Mechanical

  66. Pingback: N.K. Jemisin’s Inheritance Trilogy Is Good Stuff – pudding shot

  67. Pingback: On Fan Reactions and Awards | Ohio Needs a Train

Comments are closed.