A while back Michael D. Thomas posted a review round-up of things people were saying about Glitter & Mayhem. I’ve further distilled it down to the ones that made me curl up into a tiny ball and glow with happiness.
From Karen Burnham in the print edition of Locus:
Out of 20 stories here there are four that I would happily suggest for awards lists (the Barzak, Swirsky, El-Mohtar, and Schwartz), which is a ratio any anthology could be proud of. I was surprised at how much these stories hit my sweet spot, even though I have little interest in disco, or David Bowie, or night clubs or (before now), roller derby. In the hands of the right story-teller, even worlds far away from our own (and much, much cooler than our own) can engage and fascinate.
From Lois Tilton at Locus Online, who gave it a “Recommended” rating:
The decadent air of the cabaret is far from the overdone sameness of glittery clubs and disco balls. There is a freshness to the magic to the sacrifice that Emily learns to make, as well. A nice variation on the old fairyland exile story.
From Brit Mandelo at Tor.com:
Perhaps my favorite of the bunch was “A Hollow Play” by Amal El-Mohtar—a story with a wrenching, intimate emotional core as well as a thoughtful exploration of embodiment, attachment, and loss. The Peri and their situation are fully realized, but the reader is never overwhelmed with extraneous detail. Additionally, the relationships between women—and the acknowledgement of the real depth and potentiality of “friendship,” often represented as more shallow than romantic love—were intense and a genuine delight to read.
I’ve written my own review of the anthology on Goodreads. I continue to be staggered by the fact that Michael, Lynne, and John put together such a well-rounded collection in three months. I genuinely feel that the Kickstarter backers have got their money’s worth here. I’m also just so grateful to the editors for taking what is, by the skin of its teeth, my first novelette, especially one as weird and vulnerable as “A Hollow Play” turned out to be.